Why is it important for participants to be unaware of what the research study is about before participating in the study?

Why is it important for participants to be unaware of what the research study is about before participating in the study?

  • PDFView PDF

Why is it important for participants to be unaware of what the research study is about before participating in the study?

Why is it important for participants to be unaware of what the research study is about before participating in the study?

Abstract

Informed consent is the most essential part of research ethics. The requirement to explain an experiment to the participants who provide tissues/information in order to obtain their voluntary consent is absolutely necessary in any research project. It is an expression of respect regarding the autonomy of the person who participates in the experiment. Why and how is informed consent required and what if some information is intentionally withheld to facilitate the participation? This paper will briefly review the history of informed consent, discuss the components of an ethically valid informed consent and examine deception in research. Sometimes, deception is used in Social, Behavioral and Educational Research (SBER) in order to obtain accuracy information. Can this be justified? There is no doubt that, for some psychological and sociological experiments, the less the subjects know the better. The Bystander Apathy Experiment and the Milgram Experiment will be used here as examples that are discussed and analyzed. In general, deception is not acceptable in human studies. Occasionally, it is necessary to mislead the participants who are subjects of a study in order to obtain unbiased information. The Institute Review Board (IRB) must review very carefully the proposals that use deception or misrepresentation. The reasons that deception is necessary for the study purpose need to be justified in depth and there must be provision in the procedures to protect the participants. When the study is completed, it is essential that a debriefing by the investigator is provided that explains any deception or incomplete disclosure involved; this should also help the subjects to deal with any distress or discomfort experienced in the research.

Keywords

Autonomy

Debriefing

Deception

Informed consent

Cited by (0)

Copyright © 2012 Published by Elsevier B.V.

1

Which of these participants is acting autonomously?

a) A participant in a documentary about human interaction on buses who does not know she is being filmed.
b) A participant whose social worker helps them answer a questionnaire and fills in a question on their behalf.
c) A deaf participant who uses a signer in an interview about disability awareness.
Correct. 'A' did not give consent and the social worker in 'b' was acting paternalistically. Only 'c' is acting autonomously. Incorrect. 'A' did not give consent and the social worker in 'b' was acting paternalistically. Only 'c' is acting autonomously. Your answer has been saved.
Why is it important for participants to be unaware of what the research study is about before participating in the study?

2

What is covert research?

a) The participant is unaware of their involvement in the study
b) The participant does not know which treatment they have been given
c) The participant is anonymous
d) The participant's personal details will not be published
Correct. Covert research is where the participant does not know they are being studied. Incorrect. The answer is: covert research is where the participant does not know they are being studied.Your answer has been saved.
Why is it important for participants to be unaware of what the research study is about before participating in the study?

3

Which of these needs to be considered to gain informed consent?

a) Obtaining both written and verbal consent
b) Giving detailed information to participants
c) Discussing the potential risks and benefits of the research
d) Clarifying and reviewing the information given
e) Respecting cultural diversity
f) All of the above
Correct. Informed consent involves all of these factors.Incorrect. The answer is: informed consent involves discussing the potential risks and benefits of the research.Your answer has been saved.
Why is it important for participants to be unaware of what the research study is about before participating in the study?

4

A research participant is allowed to withdraw from a study:

a) For any reason as long as it is explained to the researcher
b) For any reason as long as the researcher gives permission to withdraw
c) For any reason without any explanation.
Correct. Participants can withdraw at any point without the need for an explanation.Incorrect. Participants can withdraw at any point without the need for an explanation.Your answer has been saved.
Why is it important for participants to be unaware of what the research study is about before participating in the study?

5

On which of these occasions has confidentiality not been broken?

a) You made notes during an interview and ask a friend to spell-check them.
b) You store your research data and statistics on a public folder on the local library computer.
c) You forget to tell inform participants that another researcher will be using your work.
d) You ask participants to sign a consent form giving permission for their details to be entered into a prize draw.
Correct. 'a' has broken confidentiality by showing the data to others who are not involved in the study; 'b' did not store the research data securely and others could have access to it; 'c' should have informed participants that another researcher may see it. Only 'd' is confidential as participants can opt to give their details if they wish. Incorrect. 'a' has broken confidentiality by showing the data to others who are not involved in the study; 'b' did not store the research data securely and others could have access to it; 'c' should have informed participants that another researcher may see it. Only 'd' is confidential as participants can opt to give their details if they wish. Your answer has been saved.
Why is it important for participants to be unaware of what the research study is about before participating in the study?

6

Which of these studies could be potentially unethical?

a) A study of the response of elderly care-home patients to watching television at mealtimes where half watch at lunchtime, and half at dinnertime.
b) Research into treatment for AIDS where half of sufferers are given treatment and the other half, a placebo.
c) A study of the effects of sleep deprivation with sufferers of insomnia.
Correct. This research does not consider the welfare of the sufferers who are not given treatment.Incorrect. 'b' is correct: This research does not consider the welfare of the sufferers who are not given treatment.Your answer has been saved.
Why is it important for participants to be unaware of what the research study is about before participating in the study?

What is the importance of describing the participants of the study in a research?

This is included as a subsection of the “Methods” section, usually called “Participants” or “Participant Characteristics.” The purpose is to give readers information on the number and type of study participants, as a way of clarifying to whom the study findings apply and shedding light on the generalizability of the ...

When the reasons for a research study are not fully disclosed to the research participants this is known as a form of?

Incomplete Disclosure is a type of deception that involves withholding some information about the real purpose of the study, or the nature of the research procedures[3].

How can participant bias affect the outcome of a study?

Therefore, participation bias can lead to a sample that is not representative of the population which is being studied and hence affect the results and conclusions drawn from the study.

How do you avoid participant errors?

How to Reduce, Avoid, or Correct Participant Bias.
To reduce acquiescence bias, the researcher should analyze the questions and adjust anyone that may appear as a favorable answer. ... .
To reduce social desirability bias, researchers should make the participants anonymous and assure the participants of confidentiality..