Crystallized and Fluid IntelligencePaolo Ghisletta, Thierry LecerfLAST MODIFIED: 22 February 2018DOI: 10.1093/obo/9780199828340-0207IntroductionThe Gf-Gc theory of cognitive abilities is a psychometric theory of intelligence based on intelligence and ability tests. Evidence in favor of the theory has largely been gathered via factor analytic and developmental studies of intelligence, but also with respect to school/education achievement and biological/genetic evidence. The theory was first formulated in terms of fluid and crystallized cognitive abilities by Raymond Cattell in 1943. The theory posits its fundamental assumption, that intelligence (or rather, human cognitive abilities) is not a unitary construct but entails the lifelong coordination of at least two classes of abilities: fluid (Gf), which refers to the ability of understanding relationships among the components of an abstract problem and using such relationships to solve the problem, and crystallized (Gc), which refers to the knowledge accumulated through experiences. Fluid abilities are general in nature, in that they can be applied to any novel abstract situation that requires solving a novel problem, while crystallized abilities are specific, in that they require specific knowledge (learned from one’s cultural milieu) to solve familiar problems (this distinction is similar to, and partially built upon, what Hebb 1942 proposed in terms of Intelligence A and Intelligence B). Two particular aspects of this hypothesis, which set it apart from previous ones, are its structural and its kinematic predictions. Structural evidence in favor of the Gf-Gc hypothesis comes from many studies showing that by relying on factor-analytic methods it is possible to demonstrate that a single factor of intelligence, called g, does not describe the relations among broad cognitive abilities, representing primary-level abilities, as well as models with multiple factors. Kinematic predictions come from studies that analyze age gradients or, more directly, age changes in cognitive performance. These studies conclude that while during childhood both classes of abilities increase, starting in young adulthood fluid abilities decrease, while crystallized abilities remain constant (or may even increase). A third set of prediction is dynamic in nature, and is captured especially by the investment theory, which postulates that during childhood fluid abilities are necessary to accumulate crystallized ones. In practice, it is certainly not simple to measure the two broadest abilities in adults; with respect to Gc abilities, because of the influence of experience, interest, motivation, professional skills, and years since schooling (on which most general Gc tests are based, like vocabulary); and as for Gf abilities, especially in older adults, processing speed generally decreases during adulthood, and most Gf tasks are timed, which leads to confounds between the two classes of cognitive tasks. Opponents of the theory have pointed out that in practice Gf is highly collinear with a general factor of intelligence (g), while Gc abilities further contribute little in terms of individual differences in cognitive performance. Show
Historical ContextIn 1943, the psychologist Raymond B. Cattell (b. 1905–d. 1998) published a highly influential paper in Psychological Bulletin entitled “The Measurement of Adult Intelligence” (he also presented portions of the paper at the 49th annual meeting of the American Psychological Association in 1941 in the form of Cattell 1941). Therein, Cattell noted the increase of adult testing during World War I, first by the US government to recruit and attribute specific positions within the army’s hierarchy, then more generally to assess intellectual abilities in children and adults. Cattell 1943 lists forty-four existing intelligence tests, which cover various domains, such as written and oral verbal, nonverbal, and perceptual abilities. However, Cattell also points out that such tests are neither standardized nor published, while the majority were conceived for college students (hence are probably not generalizable to a wider population). In the end, he notes a dearth of intelligence tests for adults of a general population. Cattell also observes that the heterogeneity of the tests stems from different theoretical perspectives on intelligence, but also from a variety of methodologies employed to validate such tests. Within this historical context, Cattell outlines the foundations of the hypothesis of fluid and crystallized ability (Gf-Gc). While this hypothesis somewhat resembles a number of other then-current propositions about intellectual human abilities, such as Intelligence A and Intelligence B (Hebb 1942), power intelligence and speed intelligence (Lorge 1936), and the distinction between energy and engines of intellect (Spearman 1927), Cattell points out the salient differences that warrant the originality of his Gf-Gc hypothesis. Nevertheless, as affirmed by Cattell 1943 (p. 179) and as pointed out in the recent review Brown 2016, Cattell’s hypothesis relies heavily on the proposition of Intelligence A and Intelligence B (Hebb 1941, Hebb 1942), to the point that, according to Brown 2016, “Cattell’s Gf-Gc theory of intelligence” should be named “the Hebb-Cattell theory.” Kent 2017 provides a brief overview of the origin of fluid and crystallized intelligence.
back to top Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content on this page. Please subscribe or login. How to SubscribeOxford Bibliographies Online is available by subscription and perpetual access to institutions. For more information or to contact an Oxford Sales Representative click here. ArticleUp
Down Which of the following philosophers described intelligence as crystalized and fluid?Raymond B. Cattell is credited with the development of the theory of fluid and crystallized intelligence. The genesis of this theory is, however, vague. Cattell, in different papers, stated that it was developed in 1940, 1941 or 1942.
What crystallized and fluid intelligence?Fluid intelligence is your ability to process new information, learn, and solve problems. Crystallized intelligence is your stored knowledge, accumulated over the years. The two types work together and are equally important. They both increase through childhood.
Who believed in crystallized intelligence?crystallized intelligence was first postulated as a psychometrically based theory by psychologist Raymond B. Cattell in 1963. He argued that fluid intelligence and crystallized intelligence are two categories of general intelligence.
What do psychologists mean by fluid intelligence and crystallized intelligence?2.1 Age-related Changes in Cognition
Fluid intelligence refers to abilities needed for abstract reasoning and speeded performance whereas crystallized intelligence refers to knowledge acquired through one's culture including verbal ability and social knowledge (Schaie 1996).
|
Which of the following philosophers describe intelligence as crystallized and fluid?
zusammenhängende Posts
Urheberrechte © © 2024 membukakan Inc.
