For what reason would an individual choose a variable annuity over a fixed annuity?

Key Points

  • An annuity pays income in retirement, can provide a guaranteed death benefit and generally provides tax deferral.
  • The five types of annuities - variable, structured, fixed index, fixed, and immediate - are designed to meet different income needs.

An annuity is a long-term insurance product. Many people purchase an annuity to provide a combination of protection through death benefit(s), tax deferral and income in retirement.

Depending on the type of annuity you purchase,you may benefit from tax-deferred growth, guaranteed retirement income and/or guaranteed death benefits. 

Each of the five annuity types offers unique benefits for individual retirement income needs:

  • Variable annuities offer the potential for greater income based on market performance. Variable annuities are complex investment vehicles that are subject to market risk, including the potential loss of principal invested.
  • Structured annuities provide opportunities for growth and a level of protection that can help eliminate some of the risk that comes with investing.
  • Fixed index annuities credit interest based on the performance of indexes using a cap or spread.
  • Fixed annuities provide a guaranteed principal* and guaranteed interest, plus are generally tax deferred. 
  • Immediate annuities provide a specific amount of income for the rest of your life or for a specified length of time.

All guarantees are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing company. These guarantees do not apply to the investments in variable annuities, which will vary with market conditions.

ANNUITIES: Annuities are not a deposit of any bank or bank affiliate, are not FDIC insured, are not insured by any federal government agency, and are not bank guaranteed. Variable and structured annuities may lose value.

*If you surrender the contract during the surrender period, surrender charges may apply, which could result in a loss of principal. 

Variable annuities are insurance products that are complex long-term investment vehicles and are subject to market risk, including the potential loss of principal invested. Before you invest, be sure to ask your financial professional about the variable annuity's features, benefits, risks and fees, and whether the variable annuity is appropriate for you, based on your financial situation and objectives. 

Withdrawals that do not qualify for a waiver may be subject to a withdrawal charge. Withdrawals are subject to income taxes and withdrawals before age 59 1/2 may incur an IRS 10% early withdrawal penalty.

Contracts and features may not be available in all states or may vary by state.

There is no guarantee that the annuity will keep up with inflation.

Most annuities have a tax-deferred feature. So do many retirement plans under the Internal Revenue code. As a result, when you use an annuity to fund a retirement plan that is tax-deferred, your annuity will not provide any necessary or additional deferral for that retirement plan. But annuities do have features other than tax deferral that may help you reach your retirement goals. You should consult your tax adviser prior to making a purchase for an explanation of the tax implications to you.

Not Federally Insured | No Financial Institution Guarantee | May Lose Value

Ameriprise Financial Services, LLC. Member FINRA and SIPC.

A variable annuity is a contract where all of the premium deposits are invested in variable subaccounts subject to market fluctuations, as opposed to a principal protected fixed interest annuity. The available subaccount options function very similar to an assortment of mutual funds that the investor can choose from, but they also have an insurance component, sometimes called an annuity wrapper.

The reasons why a person would choose to purchase a variable annuity rather than mutual funds directly, usually include the tax benefits and contract features provided by the annuity wrapper. Just like all annuity products, non-qualified variable annuities provide the opportunity for tax-deferred growth when funds are left to grow and compound inside the contract. Additionally, many variable annuities offer optional riders, for an added cost, that provide living benefits that may be helpful when preparing a retirement income strategy.

However, it is an unfortunate fact that many variable annuity riders are sold in such a way as to imply that the rider will protect investors from loss, and that with the addition of these riders their funds will be, magically somehow, insulated from market risk. This is simply NOT true. No matter what a variable annuity salesperson tells you, when you purchase a variable annuity, your funds ARE subject to market risk, which sometimes may include significant losses.

The value of a variable annuity contract is based upon the performance of the investment subaccounts that you select. These subaccounts fluctuate in value with market conditions and the principal may be worth more or less than the original cost when you decide to surrender the policy. With variable annuities, the individual annuity owner bears ALL of the investment risk. As a general rule, seniors and retirees should be reducing their investment risk as they grow older.

By contrast, with fixed annuities, the issuing insurance company assumes all of the risk and contractually guarantees the investor’s principal as well as a reasonable interest rate as defined in the contract.

Other Concerns with Variable Annuities

Fees, Fees and More Fees – One of the big drawbacks of variable annuities are the amount of fees that get charged against the investor’s account. There are investment management fees that typically range between 1.00% and 3.00%. There are mortality and expense risk charges, which according to Morningstar, average 1.35%, as well as administrative charges that usually run somewhere between 0.10% and 0.50% per year. Not to mention the additional charges incurred if optional riders are added. Putting this into perspective, if you owned a $100,000 variable annuity, and your fees totaled 3.70%, your account would be charged $3,700 every year. These fees come right off the top and are incurred even in down years, when the value of your principal is declining.

No State Guaranty Association Coverage – Every state has a Guaranty Association to help pay the claims of financially impaired insurance companies. Fixed annuities have coverage under these Guaranty Associations (up to certain limits), but variable annuities do not.

Complicated Fine Print – Variable annuities are sold by prospectus. A prospectus is a legal document, required by the Securities and Exchange Commission, which provides details about a variable annuity that is being offered for sale to the public. The problem is that a variable annuity prospectus can be extremely long; it is not uncommon for them to be hundreds of pages in length. Also, for the average investor, or even an investment representative for that matter, they are very complicated and difficult to understand.

At AnnuityAdvantage, we only offer principal protected, guaranteed and insured fixed annuity products. Consequently, the material presented in this article, and elsewhere on our website, regarding variable annuities is for informational purposes only. We are focused on educating and informing consumers regarding their annuity purchase options and assisting them in acquiring the most appropriate fixed annuities for their individual needs. We are NOT directly involved in the securities industry, nor do we market or sell variable annuities.

For what reason would an individual choose a variable annuity over a fixed annuity quizlet?

Fixed income instruments, like bonds and fixed annuities, are subject to purchasing power risk. Variable annuities provide protection from inflation because their monthly income can increase depending on the separate account's performance.

Why is a variable annuity better than a fixed annuity?

With a variable annuity, your premiums are invested in a variety of sub-account options of your choosing, and the annuity's rate of return is based on the performance of those subaccounts. Variable annuity rates are not guaranteed, and they have the potential to bring you higher returns than a fixed annuity would.

For what reason would an individual choose a variable annuity?

Variable Annuity Considerations Unlike fixed annuities, however, you control where the value in your contract will be invested. Within the limits of the investment divisions, you can be as aggressive or as conservative as you'd like. This gives a variable annuity the potential for higher returns than a fixed annuity.

Which is better a fixed or variable annuity?

Generally speaking, fixed annuities are less risky than variable annuities. Fixed annuities offer a fixed interest rate. Market volatility or company profits don't affect the interest rate on a contract. For conservative investors who seek stability and safety, a fixed annuity might be a better investment option.