Differentiation between schizoid and avoidant personalities: an empirical test
J C Overholser. Can J Psychiatry. 1989 Nov.
Abstract
A number of authors have questioned the rationale for subdividing the DSM-II schizoid diagnosis into three separate personality disorders in DSM-III, the schizoid, avoidant, and schizotypal. The present study was designed to explore differences between psychiatric patients with schizoid and avoidant personalities as compared to psychiatric controls with no personality disorder. Differences were examined on demographic data, self-report measures, and clinical information. A Multivariate Analysis of Variance (MANOVA) revealed a significant overall effect for groups across MMPI subscales. However, subsequent univariate Analyses of Variance (ANOVA's) revealed that almost all differences were between the two personality disorder groups as compared to the psychiatric controls. Contrary to expectations, schizoid and avoidant personalities were found to display equivalent levels of anxiety, depression, and psychotic tendencies as compared to psychiatric control patients. No meaningful distinctions were found between the avoidant and the schizoid personalities. Results are discussed in terms of problems with the assessment methods and the diagnostic criteria.
Comment in
Schizoid and avoidant personalities.
Brooks SA. Brooks SA. Can J Psychiatry. 1990 Jun;35(5):457-9. doi: 10.1177/070674379003500525. Can J Psychiatry. 1990. PMID: 2372758 No abstract available.
Similar articles
Interpersonal disorder in schizoid and avoidant personality disorders: an attachment perspective.
West M, Rose MS, Sheldon-Keller A. West M, et al. Can J Psychiatry. 1995 Sep;40(7):411-4. doi: 10.1177/070674379504000708. Can J Psychiatry. 1995. PMID: 8548721
Covariation of criteria sets for avoidant, schizoid, and dependent personality disorders.
Trull TJ, Widiger TA, Frances A. Trull TJ, et al. Am J Psychiatry. 1987 Jun;144(6):767-71. doi: 10.1176/ajp.144.6.767. Am J Psychiatry. 1987. PMID: 3591998
Differentiating schizoid and avoidant personality disorders.
[No authors listed] [No authors listed] Am J Psychiatry. 1986 Aug;143(8):1061-3. doi: 10.1176/ajp.143.8.aj14381061. Am J Psychiatry. 1986. PMID: 3728728 No abstract available.
Schizoid personality disorder.
Triebwasser J, Chemerinski E, Roussos P, Siever LJ. Triebwasser J, et al. J Pers Disord. 2012 Dec;26(6):919-26. doi: 10.1521/pedi.2012.26.6.919. J Pers Disord. 2012. PMID: 23281676 Review.
The comorbidity of multiple personality disorder and DSM-III-R axis II disorders.
Fink D. Fink D. Psychiatr Clin North Am. 1991 Sep;14(3):547-66. Psychiatr Clin North Am. 1991. PMID: 1946024 Review.
MeSH terms
LinkOut - more resources
Full Text Sources
- Atypon
Medical
- MedlinePlus Consumer Health Information
- MedlinePlus Health Information
The relationship between schizoid personality disorder (SPD) and avoidant personality disorder (AvPD) has been a subject of controversy for decades.[1][2]
Today it is still unclear and remains to be seen if these two personality disorders are genuinely distinct, but overlapping, personality disorders, or if they are merely two different phenotypic expressions of the same underlying disorder. Both have been associated with a shared genetic risk factor and the same polymorphism within the ANKK1 gene.[3][4] There is also some evidence that AvPD (like SPD) is a personality disorder of the schizophrenia spectrum.[5]
Originally, schizoid personality disorder involved social avoidance combined with marked ambivalence regarding the desirability of social contact. It included indifference or even cold disdain oscillating with longing for normal relationships. Through the efforts of Theodore Millon, this complex idea was later divided across two disorders with the emergence of a separate AvPD construct and the idea of ambivalence was lost.[6]
According to the differential diagnosis guidelines provided in the text of the DSM-IV the two conditions are distinguished by the extent to which the individual desires social contact versus being indifferent to it. But such distinctions are often difficult to apply in practice, as patients often have unclear, marginal, or shifting status on those elements thought most crucial for differential diagnosis. In the case of the avoidant and schizoid PDs, however, both the problem and its solution may be more academic than real. First, research indicates that all of the avoidant symptoms except social withdrawal correlate negatively with the schizoid symptom list and that differential diagnosis is not difficult.[7] Second, as pointed out by Benjamin (1993), schizoid PD is exceedingly rare and the diagnostic quandary may never occur in practice.[6]
However, new research shows that both PDs are linked to hypersensitivity.[8]
See also[edit]
- Counterdependency
References[edit]
- ^ Livesley WJ, West M (1986). "The DSM-III distinction between schizoid and avoidant personality disorders". Can J Psychiatry. 31 (1): 59–62. doi:10.1177/070674378603100112. PMID 3948107.
- ^ Winarick, Daniel J.; Bornstein, Robert F. (2015). "Toward resolution of a longstanding controversy in personality disorder diagnosis: Contrasting correlates of schizoid and avoidant traits". Personality and Individual Differences. 79: 25–29. doi:10.1016/j.paid.2015.01.026. ISSN 0191-8869.
- ^ Kendler, Kenneth S. (2010). "The Structure of Genetic and Environmental Risk Factors for DSM-IV Personality Disorders". Archives of General Psychiatry. 65 (12): 1438–1446. doi:10.1001/archpsyc.65.12.1438. PMC 2844885. PMID 19047531.
- ^ Blum K, Braverman ER, Wu S, et al. (1997). "Association of polymorphisms of dopamine D2 receptor (DRD2), and dopamine transporter (DAT1) genes with schizoid/avoidant behaviors (SAB)". Molecular Psychiatry. 2 (3): 239–46. doi:10.1038/sj.mp.4000261. PMID 9152988. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2017-02-26. Retrieved 2017-02-25.
- ^ David L. Fogelson; Keith Nuechterlein (2007). "Avoidant personality disorder is a separable schizophrenia-spectrum personality disorder even when controlling for the presence of paranoid and schizotypal personality disorders". Schizophrenia Research. 91 (1–3): 192–199. CiteSeerX 10.1.1.1019.5817. doi:10.1016/j.schres.2006.12.023. PMC 1904485. PMID 17306508.
- ^ a b Alden, Lynn E.; Laposa, Judith M. (2002). "Avoidant Personality Disorder: Current Status and Future Directions". Journal of Personality Disorders. 16 (1): 1–29. doi:10.1521/pedi.16.1.1.22558. PMID 11881158.
- ^ Trull, Timothy J.; Widiger, Thomas A.; Frances, Allen (June 1987). "Covariation of criteria sets for avoidant, schizoid, and dependent personality disorders". American Journal of Psychiatry. 144 (6): 767–771. doi:10.1176/ajp.144.6.767.
- ^ Daniel Winarick: [1]. Psychology Today, Jan. 2017.